Best Pizza in Murray Hill, New York, NY

Fresh Italian Pizza and Quick Bites in the Heart of Midtown East

Welcome To Abitino's Pizza

Our 2nd Avenue location is in the heart of Murray Hill, known for its historic brownstones and calm streets. We’re just a short walk from the Chrysler Building and Grand Central Terminal. Nearby, the United Nations Headquarters and East River Esplanade provide scenic views, while St. Vartan’s Cathedral adds historic charm. It’s a perfect spot to enjoy fresh pizza while exploring one of Manhattan’s most inviting neighborhoods.

We’re Located in Murray Hill

Address: 707 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016 Phone: +1 212-661-1919 Hours: Sunday 10 AM–10 PM Monday 10 AM–10 PM Tuesday 10 AM–10 PM Wednesday 10 AM–10 PM Thursday 10 AM–10 PM Friday 10 AM–10 PM Saturday 10 AM–10 PM

Featured

View menu

30 Years of Pizza in New York City

For more than 30 years, Abitino’s Pizza has been part of the New York City food scene. Since 1992, our family has served fresh pizza, calzones, and Italian favorites to both residents and visitors exploring the city. Over the years, our commitment to quality and friendly service helped us grow while staying true to our roots. Today, guests can visit our three Manhattan locations and enjoy the same tradition that has kept Abitino’s Pizza a trusted stop for a great slice in New York City.

Classic New York Pizza and Italian Favorites

At Abitino’s Pizza, our menu focuses on traditional Italian pizza made the New York way. Guests often order our Margherita Pizza, a simple and classic favorite. The Grandma Pizza is another popular choice with its crispy crust and rich toppings. Many customers also enjoy the Supreme Cuisine Pizza or Tony Roni’s, both packed with flavor. We also offer calzones and vegetarian options so everyone can find something they enjoy when visiting our restaurant.

Explore Our Menu

Order Direct from Abitino’s Pizza

Skip the extra steps and order straight from the Abitino’s Pizza website for a quick and easy meal. Choose your favorite pizzas like Margherita, Grandma Pizza, Supreme Cuisine Pizza, or Tony Roni’s and place your order in just a few clicks. Pick up your food at any of our three New York City locations or have it delivered right to your door. Ordering online is simple, fast, and the best way to enjoy fresh Italian pizza whenever you want.

Order Now

Fresh From Our Kitchen

Take a look at the food we prepare every day at Abitino’s Pizza. Our kitchen focuses on classic Italian favorites made fresh and served hot. From pizza and calzones to other comforting dishes, each plate reflects our family’s commitment to quality and consistency. Browse the gallery and see what guests across New York City enjoy when they visit our restaurants.

Catering from Abitino’s Pizza

Planning food for a group is easy with catering from Abitino’s Pizza. For more than 30 years, we have helped serve gatherings across New York City with fresh Italian favorites made for sharing. Our catering is a great fit for office lunches, family celebrations, birthday parties, and group events. With three locations, our team prepares every order with care so your guests can enjoy reliable, fresh food that everyone knows and loves. Let us help make your next event simple and stress-free.

Plan Your Catering

A Casual Place to Enjoy Great Pizza

Step inside Abitino’s Pizza and enjoy a casual space where good food and friendly service come together. Our restaurants are designed for quick stops, relaxed meals, and everything in between. Locals stop in for a slice during lunch, families gather for easy dinners, and visitors take a break while exploring New York City. Some locations also offer outdoor seating, giving guests a chance to enjoy their meal while taking in the energy of the city around them.

Find Abitino’s Pizza Near You 📍

Abitino’s Pizza proudly serves New York City from three convenient Manhattan locations. You can visit us at 5 W 51st St near Rockefeller Center, 707 2nd Ave in Midtown East, and 32 Broadway in the Financial District. Each location offers the same fresh Italian pizza, friendly service, and casual place to enjoy a meal. Stop by for a quick slice, sit down with family, or grab food to go while exploring the city. Wherever you are in Manhattan, Abitino’s Pizza is never far away.

Get Directions to Your Nearest Abitino’s

What our guests are saying

It took less than 60 seconds to go in and get INCREDIBLE NY style pizza. A great selection of classic drinks and super nice workers and service. Would HIGHLY recommend if you’re near!

Max G.

You want a place for a decent slice of NY pie? Look no further, especially if you’re on the East Side. I’ve never experienced a long wait time and the staff are great. HIGHLY recommend!

Joan C.

Superior customer service and delicious pizza. Many choices including the option of using a cauliflower crust! Shop is nice and clean. Love it here! Keep up the great work! Friendly team - I even call Alfredo my compadre!!